Why Reviews Matter For Property Managers

Why Google Reviews Matter for Property Managers

June 17, 20252 min read

Why Google Reviews Matter for Property Managers

If you manage multifamily properties, you already know that online visibility and resident perception can make or break your leasing efforts. But there’s one area that’s still wildly underutilized in this space — Google reviews.

Whether you oversee one building or an entire portfolio, your communities’ reputation on Google is shaping decisions long before someone books a tour.


1. Reviews Directly Impact Your Google Rankings

Google doesn’t just consider keywords or location when ranking apartment listings — it also looks at reputation signals like review quantity, frequency, and rating.

Properties with more recent 5-star reviews are more likely to show up in the Google Maps 3-pack, where the majority of clicks happen. If your property isn't there, you're losing qualified traffic to competitors who are.


2. 5-Star Reviews Build Instant Trust With Prospects

Today’s renters don’t just search for “apartments near me.” They compare, skim reviews, and form opinions in seconds. If your community has dozens of positive reviews, you create confidence before they ever hit your website.

One or two bad reviews — especially unanswered — can be all it takes to lose a lease. The flip side? A property with 100+ great reviews and timely responses stands out as professional, responsive, and resident-focused.


3. Reputation Is Easier to Automate Than You Think

The biggest barrier for most properties? Time.

That’s why services like ours exist — to help you automate review collection, respond professionally, and improve your ranking across every location you manage. It’s not about adding more to your plate. It’s about removing it — while still getting the results.


4. Review Volume Correlates With Higher Occupancy

This isn’t theory — it’s backed by data. Properties with consistent, high review volume tend to experience:

  • Higher conversion from website traffic to tours

  • Lower bounce rates on search listings

  • Fewer objections during the leasing process

  • Greater retention from residents who feel heard

In short, better reviews lead to more leases, more renewals, and a stronger brand reputation overall.


Final Thoughts

If you’re not actively managing your communities’ online reputation, you’re falling behind. The good news? It’s easier than ever to get ahead.

At The Web Optimizer, we help multifamily properties collect more 5-star reviews, rank higher on Google, and create trust that turns clicks into leases. Fully managed, done for you, and built to scale.


Want to see how it would work for your portfolio?
Book a free walkthrough →


Let me know if you'd like an alternate version focused on regional managers or a second post (e.g. “How Google Ranks Apartment Communities”).

Ben Stummer

Ben Stummer is the founder of The Web Optimizer, a reputation and local SEO service built specifically for property managers. He helps multifamily communities rank higher on Google and collect more 5-star reviews through hands-free automation. When he's not building systems that get results, Ben's focused on helping property teams scale smarter and stand out in competitive markets.

Back to Blog